Npm vs new weberian

Posted by: admin 4 months ago

(Comments)

Certainly! The New Public Management (NPM) and the New Weberian State (NWS) approaches represent two distinct models of public administration, each with different emphases and strategies for managing the public sector. Here are the key differences between them:

### 1. **Philosophical Foundation**
- **New Public Management (NPM):** Rooted in neoliberal ideas and inspired by private sector practices, NPM focuses on market-oriented approaches, emphasizing efficiency, competition, and results-based management.
- **New Weberian State (NWS):** Based on Max Weber’s traditional bureaucratic model, NWS emphasizes the importance of a strong, centralized state, the rule of law, and a professional civil service dedicated to the public good.

### 2. **Role of the State**
- **NPM:** Advocates for reducing the direct role of the state in service delivery, favoring privatization, outsourcing, and the use of market mechanisms.
- **NWS:** Reaffirms the state's central role in governance, maintaining that a strong, capable public sector is essential for ensuring equity, fairness, and the public interest.

### 3. **Management Practices**
- **NPM:** Promotes the adoption of private sector management practices, such as performance measurement, cost-cutting, and competition within the public sector. It treats citizens as customers and emphasizes service delivery based on their preferences.
- **NWS:** Focuses on maintaining traditional bureaucratic practices like merit-based recruitment, adherence to rules, and a strong public service ethos. It combines these with modern elements like greater citizen engagement and accountability but without fully embracing market-based reforms.

### 4. **Public Service Ethos**
- **NPM:** Often emphasizes efficiency and effectiveness, sometimes at the expense of traditional public service values. The focus is on delivering services efficiently, with a business-like approach to managing resources.
- **NWS:** Upholds a strong public service ethos, where serving the public interest is the primary goal. It emphasizes ethical governance, public accountability, and a commitment to the common good.

### 5. **Citizen Engagement**
- **NPM:** Views citizens primarily as customers who consume public services, with an emphasis on meeting their demands and improving satisfaction through competition and choice.
- **NWS:** Encourages citizen participation in governance but within a framework that respects the rule of law and the state's role in ensuring fairness and equity. Citizens are seen as active participants in the democratic process, not just consumers of services.

### 6. **Accountability and Transparency**
- **NPM:** Relies heavily on performance metrics, audits, and market-based mechanisms to ensure accountability and transparency, often focusing on outcomes rather than processes.
- **NWS:** Supports accountability and transparency within a more traditional bureaucratic framework, emphasizing legal accountability, the rule of law, and the importance of professional expertise.

### 7. **Decentralization vs. Centralization**
- **NPM:** Favors decentralization, allowing for local authorities or private entities to manage services, with the idea that competition and local control lead to better outcomes.
- **NWS:** While it may incorporate some elements of decentralization, NWS generally supports a more centralized approach, ensuring that the state retains control over key public functions to protect the public interest.

In summary, while NPM is focused on making public administration more like the private sector with an emphasis on efficiency and competition, the New Weberian State seeks to modernize traditional bureaucracy while preserving the core values of public service, legal authority, and the role of the state in ensuring equity and justice.

• ← Graph shows interest rate and housing in US
• Understanding the equation where unemployment is related with the national output →