Model in explaining buble

Posted by: admin 4 months, 2 weeks ago

(Comments)

Certainly! Here's a comprehensive overview of the models that explain economic bubbles, including a conclusion on which models are most effective:

### Models that Explain Economic Bubbles

Economic bubbles occur when the prices of assets such as real estate, stocks, or commodities rise rapidly to levels far beyond their intrinsic value, typically driven by exuberant market behavior. Several models have been developed to explain the formation and bursting of bubbles, each offering unique insights into the mechanisms at play.

### 1. **Greater Fool Theory**
- **Explanation**: The Greater Fool Theory suggests that bubbles are driven by the belief that one can always sell an overvalued asset to a "greater fool" at a higher price, regardless of the asset's intrinsic value. Investors buy overvalued assets with the expectation of selling them to someone else at a profit before the bubble bursts.
- **Key Proponent**: The concept doesn't have a single originator but is widely referenced in behavioral finance and economics.

### 2. **Minsky's Financial Instability Hypothesis**
- **Explanation**: Hyman Minsky's hypothesis posits that financial markets are inherently unstable due to cycles of speculative euphoria followed by market corrections. According to Minsky, periods of economic stability lead to increasing risk-taking, which eventually results in financial crises and bubbles.
- **Key Proponent**: **Hyman Minsky** (1919–1996), an American economist known for his work on financial instability.

### 3. **Rational Expectations and Bubbles**
- **Explanation**: According to this model, bubbles can form even when investors are rational, as long as they believe they can sell the asset at a higher price before the bubble bursts. This is often linked to the concept of "rational bubbles," where prices deviate from fundamental values, but investors still expect to profit.
- **Key Proponent**: **Olivier Blanchard** and **Mark Watson** in their 1982 paper "Bubbles, Rational Expectations, and Financial Markets."

### 4. **Behavioral Finance Models**
- **Explanation**: Behavioral finance explains bubbles by focusing on psychological factors like herd behavior, overconfidence, and loss aversion. These models suggest that irrational behavior among investors can drive asset prices far beyond their fundamental values.
- **Key Proponent**: **Robert J. Shiller**, who is known for his work on behavioral finance and asset bubbles. His book "Irrational Exuberance" (2000) delves into the psychological underpinnings of bubbles.

### 5. **Herd Behavior and Informational Cascades**
- **Explanation**: This model suggests that bubbles can form when individuals make decisions based on the actions of others rather than their own information or analysis. As more people follow the herd, prices inflate, creating a bubble.
- **Key Proponent**: **Abhijit V. Banerjee** developed the concept of informational cascades in his 1992 paper "A Simple Model of Herd Behavior."

### 6. **The Adaptive Expectations Model**
- **Explanation**: This model suggests that bubbles form when investors base their expectations of future prices on past trends. If prices have been rising, they expect them to continue rising, leading to self-reinforcing price increases until the bubble bursts.
- **Key Proponent**: **Phillip Cagan** discussed adaptive expectations in the context of hyperinflation, but the concept can also be extended to explain asset price bubbles.

### 7. **Ponzi Scheme and Pyramid Schemes**
- **Explanation**: While not a traditional market bubble, Ponzi and pyramid schemes create a bubble-like environment by promising high returns to earlier investors using the capital of newer investors, rather than through legitimate business activities or asset appreciation. As more investors join, the scheme appears profitable, attracting even more participants. However, these schemes are unsustainable and collapse when the influx of new investors slows, as there isn't enough new capital to pay returns to earlier investors.
- **Key Proponent**: The concept is named after **Charles Ponzi**, who orchestrated one of the most famous schemes in the 1920s. However, such schemes existed long before Ponzi's time and have been studied extensively in the context of financial fraud and market bubbles.

### Conclusion: Which Model Best Explains Bubbles?

In evaluating which model best explains bubbles, it’s important to consider the nature of the bubble in question. However, **Hyman Minsky's Financial Instability Hypothesis** and **Behavioral Finance Models** (notably by **Robert J. Shiller**) are among the most effective:

- **Minsky's Financial Instability Hypothesis** provides a macroeconomic framework that explains how prolonged periods of stability can lead to risk-taking and eventually result in a bubble. It is especially applicable to understanding bubbles that form in credit markets and broader financial systems.

- **Behavioral Finance Models**, particularly those advanced by Robert J. Shiller, offer a microeconomic perspective focused on the psychology of market participants. Shiller’s work on "irrational exuberance" is highly influential in explaining how collective over-optimism and emotional investing can inflate asset prices beyond sustainable levels.

Together, these models provide a comprehensive explanation of the dynamics behind economic bubbles, combining insights from both macroeconomic instability and individual investor behavior. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for predicting and mitigating the effects of bubbles in financial markets.

• ← What impacting buble
• What impacting inflation →